Is Activated Charcoal Safe for The Enamel?

Thursday, July 20, 2017 | By My Magic Mud

There has been a lot of chatter from dentists lately regarding the safety of activated charcoal in oral care products.

You’ll get answers from all over the spectrum, and it’s hard to conclude what’s reliable. You’ll hear, “Why yes, charcoal does wonders for my patients.” …and others say, “That stuff is like rubbing sandpaper on your teeth!”

We’re here to tell you the problem is in the question itself; a hasty generalization cannot be made either way.

Keep reading.

Regarding dentist claims against charcoal: You cannot make a categorical statement around the safety of activated charcoal for oral care. Some activated charcoal is, indeed, too abrasive, while others, depending on how it’s processed, are safe – it depends on the particle size and overall formulation within the oral care products themselves.

We, at My Magic Mud, have performed RDA (Relative Dentin Abrasion) and REA (Relative Enamel Abrasion) studies on our activated charcoal oral care line, which by American Dental Association standards, are within range of being safe. We don’t know of any other activated charcoal brands that have performed these tests.

We have dentists all over the USA recommending our products to their patients who are looking for alternatives to conventional treatments. We have a great respect for dentists who offer these alternatives, because some people can really benefit from avoiding harsh chemical treatments. These more conventional treatments work, but they can take a toll on your health and be a drain on your pocket book. Dentists cannot deny the intense sensitivity and pain that follows whitening treatments.

We think dentists who make these hasty generalizations around activated charcoal, do it because they care about their patients and because they have a healthy skepticism of practices they weren’t introduced to in dental school or peer publications; however we invite them to look at the objective standards for measuring safety when analyzing activated charcoal by itself and as a part of a greater ingredient deck in oral care products.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up today for email and receive
10% off your next purchase!

Plus, be the first to learn about special offers,new arrivals, exclusive events and more! **

Follow Us:


My Magic Mud® is dedicated to providing premium earth-sourced personal care products, while uplifting our community of suppliers, customers, and team.

Our founder and CEO Jessica Arman uses only premium, natural ingredients in My Magic Mud’s product line. Jessica knew that nature could provide powerful oral care benefits. After years of research and development, Jessica ensures every tube is enriched with simple and clean ingredients. Our products are made with premium ingredients—formulated with an uncompromising commitment to natural health and made with the highest ethical standards.

What People Are Saying
  • “I absolutely love their products! I have been on a journey of cleaning out all toxic products in my life because of the things I found that can cause issues in your body with your hormones. I was so glad that these products use clean and safe ingredients for my entire family! I can confidently use this tooth paste and know that it is not adding toxins into my body.

    Brandi
  • “Our household has been using the My Magic Mud, Activated Charcoal Oral Rinse( Alcohol Free) for about 2 weeks now. When we first got it and opened it, I have to say the smell was extremely strong but when you rinse with it, it’s not as strong as it smells. I love how clean my mouth feels after using this product. I don’t typically use mouth wash because I just don’t like the taste of them. With the My Magic Mud, the taste is so smooth it doesn’t bother me. I recommend this product to anyone looking for a new mouth rinse.

    Angela
  • “I’ve been using it for a year and I’ve tried the wintergreen and spearmint but I would have to say peppermint is my favourite because of how the peppermint feels. It is also super natural and safe that I put it on my hives that I had and they went away and felt instantly better after I put it on! I love this product so much :)

    Sydney
  • “Received some at the Natural Products Expo; really love it and came looking for a Cyber Monday Deal. All I want for Christmas is a water filter and this toothpaste! For some reason, it makes me enjoy brushing my teeth. I'm slowly switching out all toxic products in my household, and am very happy with the ingredients (and results) of Magic Mud. I like the paste when I'm short on time, and the powder for a deep clean. One quick wipe will do the trick for keeping your sink clean - 10 seconds tops. Don't use it for your first time while you're running late for work though

    Taya
  • “I love MAGIC MUD! I've been using it for the past few years and I will not be going back to anything else. I began using Magic Mud because I was getting burns on the corners of my mouth from regular toothpaste. I actually bought some at the New Braunfels farmers market the first time and was completely sold by my second use. I'm so proud to use a local product too.

    Erin
  • “I'd been curious about/following this page for months, but I'd found it right after I bought a more expensive (almost double the price!) whitening toothpaste. I was lucky enough to win a tube of the paste right around Thanksgiving. The customer service was incredible, and shipping was super-fast! I noticed a difference immediately: within the first two weeks, it had outperformed the more expensive paste - without tooth sensitivity!! I just bought the polish too, because I figure it's probably a great boost - and I intend to be a long-term customer. Thank you for making this product!! I'm already smiling more, and I love that my nephews are creeped out/fascinated by it

    Madeleine
  • “Love the name, love the packaging, love the flavor, love the clean-feeling teeth, but more than anything i just love the dirty grimy black n' nasty "sludgemouth" i get when using this glorious product. sure it might stain the ol' kitchin sink a little bit but a little desecration and blasphemy never hurt anybody amirite??? After being prescribed/pushed/recommended "extra-strength extra-fluoride prescription toothpaste [clinpro 5000]" from my dentist, i proudly and brazenly hucked that abominable tube of sorry toothlube away forever once i picked up a ripe slice of this unholy magma I recommend the motherlovin' heck out of this abzu-lutely lifechanging product

    Mark
  • “My Magic Mud is the most natural dentifrice on the market. The product is full of surprises as it both cleans your teeth and makes them whiter. Imagine using a black toothpaste to make your teeth SPARKLE.

    Donald Newman, DDS
  • “I am a Biological Dentist and “My Magic Mud” is a product I use being that it is 100% all natural, improves your oral health and makes your teeth brighter and whiter.

    Dr. Merrily M. Sandford, DDS